Celebrating the greatest show in the galaxy's 60th birthday, with a run-down of every TV story from all eras worst to best across 315 days up until the anniversary on November 23rd 2023 for all new fans arriving from the 'Whoniverse' on BBC i-player. Remember, a Dr Who story a day keeps the entropy away! Sister site to music review site 'Alan's Album Archives' (www.alansalbumarchives.blogspot.com) and sci-fi book series 'Kindred Spirits' (www.kindredspiritbooks.blogspot.com)
Wednesday, 2 August 2023
The Web Of Fear: Ranking - 109
The Web Of Fear
(Season 5, Dr 2 with Jamie and Victoria, 3/2/1968-9/3/1968, producer: Peter Bryant, script editor: Derrick Sherwin, writers: Mervyn Haisman and Henry Lincoln, director: Douglas Camfield)
Rank: 109
'Underground overground wobbling free
The abominable snowmen otherwise known as yeti
Making the most of the web guns they fire
The Great Intelligence's furry army for hire'
Why are the yeti, a big splash
during their debut in the hills of Tibet just a few weeks ago in DW,
hiding out in London’s Underground? Nobody knows. Why do they have
web guns now? Nobody knows that either. Why have they regenerated and
become less cuddly? Nobody even seems to notice. What we do know is
that for 45 years this story was accepted as one of those top tier DW
classics that we would never get to see again – and then it was
returned (or 4/6ths of it were anyway) in time for the series’ 50th
anniversary. That web of intrigue behind their recovery is
complicated enough to make its own action packed six part film one
day: suffice to say this is one of those stories that has grown quite
a cult following down the years and still feels rather magical and
mystical, despite the fact that we can now own it as a physical
object and file it away amongst our other DVDs. As a result this
story holds a special place in many a fans’ heart, although getting
to the bottom of why it does is a bit trickier than it is with other,
more obvious recovered classics like ‘Tomb Of The Cybermen’ or
indeed what we have left of ‘The Abominable Snowman’. Mostly this
is six episodes of running around in the dark, like a giant game of
hide and seek, while trying to work out which of the UNIT soldiers is
a spy, with barely a break away from that main plot: hardly the most
taxing DW affair. Mostly its an exercise in atmosphere and tension
that doesn’t make much sense written down (indeed the novelisation
is one of the weakest I always thought). What an atmosphere though:
you’ll never go on the tube again without wondering what might be
lurking just out of sight. This is a properly scary DW story, one
where the tension is high at the start (in the one episode we always
had) and only gets greater and greater after that. This story is set
forty odd years after the first Yeti tale, though screened all of
twelve weeks after it, when the originals would have still been fresh
in everybody’s minds. It’s a nice play on the Tardis’
time-travelling abilities that sometimes gets lost in the 2nd
Dr era (when the Tardis starts becoming transport rather than the
magic box and home away from home of the Hartnell era) and its fun to
see Jack Watling (one of DW’s most famous guest stars, who just
happens to be the dad of the actress playing companion Victoria)
dressed up to look decades older and going from a middle aged action
hero to a senile old man with a middle aged daughter of his own,
while the Tardis crew haven’t aged a day (well, three months or so
– its really interesting that they were so sure the first story was
going to be a hit that they commissioned a sequel before it had even
gone out). There’s the much-lauded entrance of the Brigadier whose
going to hang around for the next seven years and the first shots of
UNIT, although neither are quite how we imagine them just yet –
full praise to Nicholas Courtney for making so much of what’s not
such a great part yet (the Brig is so shifty he appears to be the
human collaborator for a good half of the story and the first time we
see more of him than just his feet is when he’s pointing a gun at
Victoria, hardly normal Brig behaviour). UNIT are a great invention
too, even if here they’re just a new name for the same old lot of
soldiers – if anything its long overdue that Britain should only
get its own designated alien-fighting army division at this point, in
near-contemporary 1968, after invasions by Daleks, Ice Warriors and
multiple groups of Cybermen. The yeti clearly make a lot more
realistic sense in Tibet, but moving them to the London underground
(the natural home of more than a few viewers watching this – no,
not the actual underground having re-read that sentence, but you know
what I mean, a place everyone knew of and a lot of people had used)
really nails one of the things that makes DW great, turning the
ordinary you see every day into something extraordinary that reminds
us what a mind-bogglingly big and strange place the universe might be
and how small out part is in it. After all, you can’t get more
ordinary and realistic than a dark place full of manmade trains –
or more DWish than a lumbering hairy beastie set to kill us all. As
always it goes without saying that the regulars are superb – even
Victoria is less wet than she often is as being against her dad makes
her up her game, while Patrick Troughton and Frazer Hines have worked
together long enough by now to improvise their way round the dialogue
and nail every line instinctively. The sound of this story is
particularly memorable too: the warbling when the ‘great
intelligence yeti balls’ start moving of their own accord is one of
the great memorable sounds of DW and the music soundtrack is one of
the better ones too, really adding to the fear and menace (it was
almost a shame when we finally had pictures to go with the
soundtrack, given all the things my imagination had come up with). So
how does a story this full of scares, ideas and acting possibly
disappoint? Well, as much as the script builds up episode by episode
it also repeats itself a lot. Of all the six-parters in DW this is
the one I’d take the scissors to most: there are six full episodes
set in the underground without a break and while there’s a lot of
mystery over who the baddy might be and where exactly the yeti are,
this is one of the few stories where you could jump from the first
episode to last without really having missed much (it doesn’t help
that Patrick Troughton’s on holiday for part two and the plot
struggles to do anything without the Doctor there). We also never
find out how the yeti end up down the underground: there’s only one
scene where the great intelligence gets to talk to the Doctor at all
and he (She? It? Can a disembodied voice have a gender?) never
reveals that much. As scary as the yeti is when close-up on screen
and roaring (in reality the sound of a toilet flushing slowed down,
which is a lot more effective than it sounds) for the most part they
don’t do a lot and a lot of the threat relies on you remembering
how scary they were last time (plus I rather liked the cuddlier look
– and why would a voice and a bunch of robots feel such need for
cosmetic surgery anyway?) Dare I say it, the second half of this
story is a little bit boring and the story as a whole is, like many a
sequel, a lot sillier and less interesting all round than the
impressive debut. Nevertheless that’s just a reason why this story
isn’t one of my very favourites or as high as a lot of fans would
put it – this is still a great atmospheric story, one that even in
the ‘monster’ season full of bases under siege is properly scary
and full of new inventive ideas that will last on DW far into the
future. Far from ‘abominable’ in other words.
+ Those underground sets really
are extraordinarily lifelike and a real triumph for the design team.
The story goes that DW’s production office got in touch with the
real London underground to ask if they wanted to be featured in a
story where people who ventured down to their stations were zapped by
yeti robots and died a gruesome death; unsurprisingly they said no
(honestly, its a bigger surprise so many similar organisations said
yes to DW down the years). They couldn’t stop the BBC manufacturing
their own sets though and the attention to detail, down to the
railway sleepers and the mock near-future posters, is glorious. The
chap at the underground who turned them down happened to see the
first episode go out on TV and was so convinced the BBC had really
filmed in the underground despite his refusal that he rang up to
complain and was only mollified when someone sent him a photograph of
the sets under construction. If they could fool him they could fool
anybody and they’re a huger part of why this story works as well as
it does. Oh and Pink Floyd fans should check out the names of the
UNIT personnel, ‘Arnold’ and ‘Lane’, which might well be a
topical joke about them being the first ‘underground’ band the
writers could think of (or might just be coincidence). Sadly nobody
sees a yeti called Emily play to confirm the point. In retaliation
(or another coincidence) Pink Floyd return the favour by riffing on
the Doctor Who theme tune during their instrumental ‘One Of These
Days’ from the ‘Meddle’ LP in 1971.
- A lot of 1960s DW stories have
a ‘token’ comedy character. While not as bad as, say, Pigbin Josh
(unlikely yokel stereotype eaten by an orange bouncy castle) or
Morton Dill (New Yorker on the Empire State Building who thinks the
Daleks are a magic trick but amazingly doesn’t get
exterminated...worst luck) Harold Chorley is still extremely
irritating and doesn’t have any plot function except getting in the
way. Apparently he’s the writers’ idea of David Frost, getting
under people’s noses in the middle of an emergency and asking them
stupid questions about how they’re feeling world seems doomed, but
David Frost was never that irritating (Chorley’s actually a lot
more like Robert Peston, though he was all of eight when this story
went on air). No serious army would ever tolerate his presence, but
then UNIT never seem that serious an army organisation even here in
their first appearance, what with blowing tunnels up without checking
whose down them (the Doctor as things turn out..), letting civilians
roam around instead of cornering it off and not really having much of
a plan which soldiers to send where. This will only get worse when
UNIT become regulars, strangely.
No comments:
Post a Comment