Celebrating the greatest show in the galaxy's 60th birthday, with a run-down of every TV story from all eras worst to best across 315 days up until the anniversary on November 23rd 2023 for all new fans arriving from the 'Whoniverse' on BBC i-player. Remember, a Dr Who story a day keeps the entropy away! Sister site to music review site 'Alan's Album Archives' (www.alansalbumarchives.blogspot.com) and sci-fi book series 'Kindred Spirits' (www.kindredspiritbooks.blogspot.com)
Wednesday, 24 May 2023
Pyramids Of Mars: Ranking - 179
Pyramids Of Mars
(Season 13, Dr 4 with Sarah Jane,25/10/1975-15/11/1975, producer: Phillip Hinchcliffe, script writer: Robert Holmes, writer: Stephen Harris (aka Robert Holmes and Lewis Griefer), director: Paddy Russell)
It’s
the Mummy’s curse story with scifi overtones, the
one where
Tom Baker and Sarah Jane Smith facing down a giant mummy and an alien
buried in a pyramid who turns out to have God-like powers. As a fully
signed up Egyptologist and Whovian (though
some people don’t like that term. Whoover?
Whore? What is the proper term these days?) this story
sounds
right up my street. It’s certainly not bad: the regulars give their
all, Gabriel Woolf’s whispery turn as Sutekh is why
sofas were made for hiding behind
despite being
in a mask throughout and only
really having his voice to work with and as 1970s production values
go I’ll happily soak up all the mummy costumes, model shots of
pyramids and alien spaceships (even if, for
once,
the modern series did mummy effects quite
a
bit better). Given that this is another one of those DW stories
conceived, written and shot to order in a ridiculously short space of
time after other ideas
fell through at
the last minute as they so often did, it’s
a wonder its as good as it is. To
many fans it’s the best single story DW ever did and pharoah nuff
as it were – it does feature one of the best Doctors, one of the
best companions and one of the best baddies after all. I’ve
always felt there was something slightly hollow about this story
though, that it doesn’t give you the extras DW usually gives you
especially
in this golden era,
that there are no shiny b-plots, no little bits of magic
dialogue
to
make things sparkle(despite
being written by Robert Holmes under a pseudonym whose
usually so strong on that sort of thing),
no twists or turns to keep the thing going. Like the pyramid itself
this story only has one point throughout
and
that’s a straight fight between the Doctor and Sutekh; every scene
pretty much revolves around this, without the usual DW storytelling
brilliance of detail, background and motivation. It’s just a bad
guy whose been asleep for several centuries who wants to take over
the world, stopped by a good guy
in a long scarf who
wants Humans to be free.
Even
this basic story is
recycled from Egyptian folklore, a little too obviously: there really
was a war between Set (aka Sutekh) and Horus (Osiruses’ father and
thus the founder of the Osirians, Sutekh’s
home race)
that ended up with the former being imprisoned for 7000 years. As
far as I know he never did arrive in England in 1911, but an awful
lot of Egyptian texts revolve around the fact that he will one day
and what that might be like so it’s not that big a leap to make it
a DW plot. Now that’s not unique to this story. A
lot of the Hinchcliffe years are recycled from some
other source
and this is no different to the other popular
stories
around it that riff on Frankenstein or Dracula or Sherlock Holmes or
(endlessly) Quatermass, but this one seems even more of a cheat than
usual. I mean, even the scifi elements are in the original Egyptian
text as their Gods all came from outer space. In
short, if
I had to write a DW story to order in a short space of time because
nothing else was working and I had no ideas then that’s
exactly what I’d do too: look for a suitable text that already
exists and embellish it. The thing about ‘Pyramids’ compared to
other stories that do the same is that there aren’t really that
many embellishments though
and
for once with Holmes even the dialogue isn’t as strong as normal,
perhaps showing what a rush-job this was (the only real comedy is the
bit Tom and Lis Sladen added, the farcical bit where they nearly walk
into the mummy then back off and walk away, something they added
despite despite the director telling them not to!) For a story that
spends
so much time discussing tribophysics (the idea of friction being
three things in movement at once) there’s only one source of
friction all story – everyone but Sutekh might as well have gone
home. For all that though I can see why so many people love this
story as they do. The acting is superb, every last person making the
most of their part and making things seem a hundred times more
frightening than by rights they ought to be on
paper.
There are so many striking images that stick long in the memory too:
the mummy let loose in the grounds while Sarah Jane desperately tries
to shoot it to no avail, the mummy that turns out to be the Doctor
(the director persuading Tom Baker to be in the costume himself when
none of the extras could copy his distinctive walk!), the organ that
continues to play even after manservant
Ibrahim
has left it and been reduced to a smoky pulp by Sutekh, the destroyed
parallel Earth when the Doctor nips forward in time to show Sarah
exactly what’s at stake if Sutekh gets his way (why
doesn’t the Doctor do that in more stories then eh?),
Mick Jagger’s beautiful Stargroves estate doubling as Scarman’s
estate, err the much
loved fan moment when the
production assistant’s hand holds
down Sutekh’s cushion on screen when he gets up to rant (even
Egyptian Gods can’t control their own cushions, I have the same
trouble). There’s enough action and spills and thrills and classy
cliffhangers to keep you watching every week for
a month and
re-watching in
an hour and a half quite
happily. It’s only afterwards, when you stop to think about it,
that you see the inconsistencies and plotholes. Admittedly all DW
stories have gaps in logic if you look at them and squint long
enough, as with most fiction, but this one has more issues
than
most (How
come in
all this time no
one has noticed the mummies on patrol outside? There isn’t even a
rumour about
something strange going on. I mean, surely they had a paper boy or a
visit from the council?
How come sending Sutekh through a time corridor ages him –
shouldn’t it be like the Weeping Angels in reverse so he just comes
out the other side the same age? Why are we in England in 1911 after
all? Shouldn’t we be in Egypt?!? And why didn’t the Ice Warriors
intercept the beam from Mars before
us?
– it’s their home planet after all). DW still hasn’t quite
done Ancient Egypt properly in other words, even though it seems the
most obvious time and place for him to go to, which is a crying
shame
as with the mythology and the scifi leanings there’s a potentially
brilliant
story waiting to be written there rather than the slightly
rushed
one we get here. Even so, a great breathless
runaround
with Tom Baker at his peak facing off one of the best baddies the
show ever had is more than worthy of a place mid-tier in this
ranking, if maybe not quite as high as other fans would put it.
+
Sutekh. It’s not everyone who can pull off a 7000 year old alien
with magic powers even though their face is hidden by a mask but
Gabriel Woolf is the latest in a long line of whispering Who villains
who manage to be all the creepier for the fact they speak in low
voices
not shouted rants. Sutekh nonchalantly offering ‘my gift of death’
as he kills off most of the cast alone
puts
him in the top tier of creepy
Who
villains. For a while there he really does seem unstoppable. If the
‘real’ Set was like this no wonder Ancient Egypt built so many
pyramids in his honour.
-
Talking
of which, where
are the pyramids? I know Sutekh has one for a spaceship but...this is
a story about ancient Egypt and all we see of the
ancient wonder of the world
is one blooming door of
a boring tomb with
the eye of Horus on it (no guessing what symbol most DW fans would
pick on ‘Only Connect’!) Instead of the really interesting
backstory and discovery of the tomb in one of the most fascinating
places on the planet, we’re stuck for
four episodes in
one English estate in 1911 that badly needs some decorators (no don’t
be cross Mick, I meant the set of the inside not Stargroves which
looks gorgeous).
We don’t even get to see Mars properly
and we’ve been there so many times by now they could have mocked
the planet up in five minutes.
No comments:
Post a Comment